Connect with us

MEDIA FOR CHANGE NETWORK

Opinion: Why is IFC contributing to poverty in Guinea?

Published

on

Market in Guinea

While most of the world was sheltering in place due to the COVID-19 pandemic in March, a hundred families were uprooted from their lush, centuries-old village in western Guinea and relocated to a barren hilltop to make way for a sprawling bauxite mine, backed by the International Finance Corporation.

Residents of the Hamdallaye village say the Compagnie des Bauxites de Guinée, or CBG, moved them to an unfinished resettlement site that lacks adequate housing, water, and arable land to replace the farmland that the company has taken from them over the past decade.

Three months later, World Bank President David Malpass responded to the Black Lives Matter movement by committing to tackle racial injustice and inequality, including within the World Bank Group. A banner reading “#EndRacism” was draped across the façade of the bank’s headquarters in Washington.

If these words are to be more than just a hashtag, the bank should take a hard look at how it is deepening inequality by contributing to the plunder of African resources, at the expense of African lives, to help some of the wealthiest corporations accumulate more wealth.

One of the world’s largest bauxite miners, CBG is a joint venture of the Guinean government and three multinational mining companies — Rio Tinto, Alcoa, and Dadco — and supplies the raw material for aluminum in an array of consumer products, from Ford trucks and BMW luxury cars to Campbell’s soup and Coca-Cola cans.

In 2016, the company received a package of loans estimated at $795 million from IFC, the U.S. Overseas Private Investment Corporation, and a syndicate of commercial banks to expand its bauxite production. The German government guaranteed a portion of the financing through its untied loan guarantees program.

Last year, the residents of Hamdallaye joined 12 other villages in filing a complaint with IFC’s independent watchdog, the Compliance Advisor Ombudsman, or CAO, saying CBG had grabbed their ancestral land, polluted their water sources, and caused long-term damage to their livelihoods with IFC’s acquiescence.

The company responded to the complaint, as well as others, by saying that it has adopted and adhered to IFC’s environmental and social performance standards over the past four years but that it “wishes to learn more about the concerns expressed in the complaint and initiate a process to resolve the disputes with the Complainants.”

The communities and the company were scheduled to begin mediations in April 2020 under the auspices of CAO. The people of Hamdallaye expected to have this opportunity to negotiate their resettlement terms on a fair footing. Mediations were postponed due to the coronavirus pandemic, yet CBG plowed ahead with the resettlement of the village regardless. The company has since issued a statement about this.

To help Hamdallaye and the other communities prepare for mediations, my organization, Inclusive Development International, supported them to conduct a participatory mapping exercise and to analyze Earth observation data from 1974 to 2019. This mapping documented and geolocated the impacts of CBG’s operations on 17 villages.

The results were staggering, suggesting that the residents of these villages — which make up only a small fraction of the roughly 230 villages affected by CBG’s expansion — collectively lost more than 100 water sources and more than 80 square kilometers of cropland to CBG’s mining activities. The company has yet to pay a cent in compensation for this land.

What’s worse, CBG is not rehabilitating most of the land it exploited. Bauxite mining strips vast areas of fertile topsoil to access the minerals underneath, creating “dead zones” that are useless for agriculture without proper rehabilitation. An analysis of satellite imagery indicates that over the lifetime of the mine, the company has rehabilitated only about 10% of the land that it has exploited, and large portions have been re-mined since the IFC-backed expansion began in 2016.

The land that CBG and other bauxite miners are destroying underpins the economic and food security of some 400,000 farmers in the Boké region. Far from bringing development to this corner of West Africa, this investment threatens to cause impoverishment on a massive scale.

So why is a member of the World Bank Group, along with the U.S. and German governments, fostering poverty in what is already one of the world’s poorest nations?

The project backers said that CBG’s expansion would benefit social development and stimulate economic growth in Boké. IFC acknowledged the investment’s significant risks but justified them on the basis of the environmental and social “additionality” that it would bring, pledging to “support the Company in areas such as biodiversity, resettlement and water management.” The loan package is predicated on CBG’s commitment to comply with its environmental and social performance standards.

CBG has not only failed to acknowledge and redress its 30-year legacy of harm, but it is still not complying with IFC’s standards as it expands its operations over vast new areas of land. That is not just our analysis but also the conclusion of the project’s independent environmental and social monitor.

CBG’s unwillingness to remediate and avoid further harm may have been tolerated by the lenders so far, but it is causing enormous frustration among the local population. In 2017, Boké saw large-scale riots by thousands of young people protesting bauxite mining in the region, resulting in multiple deaths of protestors at the hands of security forces. The protesters weren’t saying no to mining; they were simply demanding a fair share of the benefits.

CBG’s multinational owners do not actually need IFC’s advice on how to mine bauxite more responsibly. After a lengthy legal battle, Rio Tinto reached an agreement with Indigenous landowners to lease the site of its Gove mine in Australia’s Northern Territory. Rio agreed to pay the communities between $15 million and $18 million a year in rent over a 42-year period, along with a range of other development and employment benefits.

The people of Guinea deserve nothing less. And we expect no less from a “development” project that has benefited greatly from the largesse of our public tax dollars.

 Original Post: Devex

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MEDIA FOR CHANGE NETWORK

Seed Sovereignty: East African Farmers Push for Laws to Protect Indigenous Seeds and Biodiversity

Published

on

Nairobi-Stakeholders in farmer-managed systems across Africa meeting in Nairobi are pushing for strict legislation to protect indigenous seeds and safeguard traditional farming knowledge.

At the 1st Eastern Africa Indigenous Seeds Conference, farmers, researchers, policymakers, and civil society organisations from across Eastern Africa are calling for greater recognition and protection of farmer-managed seed systems against agricultural practices they say threaten traditional farming systems and biodiversity.

The four-day Conference, convened by Seed Savers Network, runs from November 17th to 20th, 2026, under the theme “Realising the Right to Food through Seed Sovereignty.”

The conference seeks to strengthen farmer-managed seed systems, promote agricultural biodiversity and advance farmers’ rights to save, exchange, use and improve indigenous seeds.

Speaking at the opening of the conference, Seed Savers Network Director Dr Daniel Wanjama warned that the lack of farmer-managed system-friendly laws not only exposes the farmer but also puts nations at risk of hunger.

“When we have 80% of food consumed being produced by millions of smallholder farmers, we cannot afford to have laws and policies that fail to protect such a critical group of people within the food value chain,” said Wanjama.

Wanjama cited Kenya, where he said a lack of farmer-managed system policies has seen the country lose 30% of its indigenous seed and plant varieties in the past 20 years.

Beatrice Wangui, a smallholder farmer and indigenous seed custodian, said protecting traditional seed varieties was essential to preserving Africa’s agricultural heritage and ensuring farmers retained control over what they grow.

She noted that indigenous seeds, passed down through generations, were adapted to local environmental conditions and offered farmers an important alternative as climate change increasingly disrupted agricultural production.

“These seeds are part of our heritage. Our parents and grandparents preserved them, not because they had no alternatives, but because they understood their value. Today, we are being pushed towards commercial seeds, yet we must not lose the freedom to save, replant and share the seeds that have sustained our communities for generations,” she said.

Katrin Voss-Rosa, Director of Luxemburg Foundation East Africa, argued that industrial agriculture was not benefiting the smallholder farmer.

She called on the donor community to shift focus from industrial food production funding and instead channel it to organic farming, which she says produces healthier food.

Van-Rosa warned that over-reliance on seeds susceptible to pest attacks and on fertilisers that affect soil health was not helping Africa’s food situation.

“We cannot be food secure and sovereign when we keep the indigenous farmer out of the equation,’’ she said.

The conference comes at a critical time, as the East African Legislative Assembly is expected to debate the East African Community Seed and Plant Varieties Bill, 2025, which seeks to harmonise seed registration, certification, marketing, and plant breeders’ rights across the region.

However, farmer organisations and civil society groups have raised concerns that the proposed regional legislation could undermine farmer-managed seed systems if it fails to recognise indigenous varieties and traditional seed-sharing practices adequately.

EALA MP David Ole Sankok said the regional legislature was committed to passing the proposed Bill to protect local seed varieties.

He warned that East Africa cannot afford to continue relying on exotic seeds, which he says has turned Africa into a net importer of food.

“We have four seed companies controlling almost 50% of the global seed market. This exposes the continent to the threat of biological warfare’’ said Sankok.

The conference is also expected to discuss the role of community seed banks in ensuring access to locally adapted varieties, preserving indigenous knowledge and helping communities recover from climate-related shocks.

Beyond food security, the conference will explore the conservation of indigenous livestock breeds, tree seeds and underutilised crops as important components of agricultural biodiversity.

Another expected outcome of the conference will be the establishment of a regional community of practice bringing together farmers, researchers, seed custodians, civil society organisations and policymakers to share evidence, strengthen partnerships and coordinate action beyond the conference.

According to the organisers, the initiative will provide a sustained platform for regional collaboration and ensure that the concerns and experiences of farming communities inform future agricultural policies.

Source: panafricanvisions.com

Continue Reading

MEDIA FOR CHANGE NETWORK

African women will present research findings on indigenous seeds, nutrition, and climate resilience in Nairobi, Kenya.

Published

on

Farmers from 9 African countries who have champiioned the conversation on food and nutrition explain the nutritional benefits of the crops that they grow in their communities at their exhibition stall in Nairobi

By the Witness Radio Team.

Today, Thursday, November 19, the African Women’s Collaborative for Healthy Food Systems will present findings from its farmer-led research on indigenous seeds, African foods, and climate-resilient crops. This will take place during a side event at the First Eastern Africa Indigenous Seed Conference in Nairobi, Kenya.

The event, titled Indigenous Seeds, Nutrition and Resilience: Findings and Recommendations from Farmer-Led Research, will take place from 11:00 am to 12:30 pm at the Catholic University of Eastern Africa in Nairobi.

For those unable to attend in person, Witness Radio will broadcast the event live on its radio platform and social media channels, including YouTube.

The side event will present key findings and recommendations from two research reports: Empirical Study on Nutritional African Foods and Nutritional Assessment of Ten Climate-Resilient Food Crops.

This research documents the nutritional, cultural, economic, and agroecological value of local African foods. It shows how these foods support communities, preserve cultural knowledge, sustain rural livelihoods, and strengthen farming systems suited to their environments.

The event will facilitate discussion on how indigenous foods and climate-resilient crops can strengthen diverse food systems while recognizing the knowledge and practices of farming communities, particularly women who are key stewards of local foods and seeds.

Participants will review the research findings, examine the reports, and collaborate on strategies to support diverse and nutritious food systems resilient to climate challenges.

The African Women’s Collaborative for Healthy Food Systems is a Pan-African initiative that brings together peasant and indigenous women leaders and their organizations. Since 2017, the Collaborative has supported rural and indigenous women in shaping Africa’s food systems.

The Collaborative advocates for women’s rights and recognizes their contributions to food production, seed conservation, agroecology, and promoting nutritious local foods. It acknowledges women farmers as both producers and guardians of indigenous seeds and ancestral knowledge.

Through its Nutritional African Foods Initiative, the Collaborative promotes knowledge about foods grown by African rural women, who use agroecological methods and local resources to feed their communities.

The Nairobi side event brings together farmers, researchers, seed custodians, policymakers, and civil society organizations from Eastern Africa for the inaugural Eastern Africa Indigenous Seed Conference, held from November 17 to 20.

With the theme Realizing the Right to Food through Seed Sovereignty, the conference aims to empower farmer-managed seed systems and highlight farmers’ role in conserving, selecting, saving, exchanging, and using indigenous seeds.

Seed Savers Network organizes this gathering, providing a regional platform to share experiences, address policy challenges, and build alliances to protect indigenous seeds and agricultural biodiversity.

The Collaborative’s side event will contribute to these discussions by highlighting the connections between indigenous seeds, women’s knowledge, nutrition, and the resilience of local food systems.

The event will be broadcast live on Witness Radio and social media platforms on Thursday, November 19, from 11:00 am to 12:30 pm (East Africa Time).

Continue Reading

MEDIA FOR CHANGE NETWORK

Farmers’ seed systems take centre stage as the first Eastern African Indigenous Seed Conference opens in Kenya.

Published

on

By Witness Radio team.

Nairobi, Kenya: Farmers, indigenous communities, researchers, policymakers, and seed-saving practitioners from across Africa and beyond have gathered in Nairobi for the first Eastern African Indigenous Seed Conference, calling for greater recognition and support for farmer-managed seed systems.

The four-day conference, which opened today, November 17, at the Catholic University of Eastern Africa, seeks to strengthen indigenous seed systems, promote seed sovereignty and create space for farmers to influence policies governing seeds and agriculture.

Organized by Seed Savers Network (SSN) and its partners, the gathering comes amid growing concerns over the future of indigenous seeds, local livestock breeds and traditional knowledge systems that communities have relied on for generations.

Opening the conference, Mr. Daniel Wanjama, the Executive Director of Seed Savers Network, said farmers remain central to the region’s seed systems, despite receiving limited recognition in agricultural policies and government support programs.

He said an estimated 80 per cent of the seeds used in the region come from farmers themselves, a contribution he said should be reflected in agricultural policies and investment priorities.

“80 per cent. It means if we cannot have indigenous seeds as we use, it means we cannot have food security. We cannot feed ourselves unless we have indigenous seeds,” Wanjama said.

He argued that governments and development organizations have concentrated much of their attention on the commercial seed sector while overlooking the contribution of farmers who save, exchange and replant seeds within their communities.

According to Wanjama, this has created a disconnect between agricultural policies, government support and the actual practices through which farmers access planting materials.

He also warned that agricultural biodiversity in Africa faces significant threats, arguing that protecting farmer-managed seed systems is important for maintaining the diversity needed to respond to climate change.

“We are facing climate change, and the only way we can survive climate change is through this agricultural biodiversity. Therefore, we cannot afford to lose it because if we lose it, we also lose our life,” he said.

Mr. Wanjama said the conference should provide an opportunity for farmers and organizations across the continent to strengthen their cooperation, exchange knowledge and jointly advocate for policies that recognize indigenous seeds.

He also called for greater farmer participation in policy discussions, saying previous conferences and discussions have not adequately reflected farmers’ experiences and concerns.

He said organizers wanted farmers to form a significant part of the conference and take an active role in discussions, rather than simply attend sessions led by experts and policymakers.

The conference is also taking place against the backdrop of ongoing debates over seed laws and farmers’ rights in Kenya, and East Africa as a region.

Mr. Francis Ngiri, a Kenyan farmer attending the conference, said restrictions on the sharing, exchange and sale of indigenous seeds remain a major concern for smallholder farmers.

In 2025, Ngiri and other farmers won a court case challenging provisions of Kenya’s 2012 Seed and Plant Varieties Act, which restrict farmers from saving, exchanging and sharing seeds. However, the government announced plans to appeal the ruling, arguing that it weakened key provisions of the law.

“We have formally launched an appeal in the Court of Appeal to contest this judgment and restore the legal backing required for strict enforcement of seed quality,” Simon Maina, head of Seed Certification and Plant Variety Protection at the Kenya Plant Health Inspectorate Service (KEPHIS), told The Star in an article published on November 4.

But Ngiri hopes the conference will help strengthen farmers’ efforts to defend their seed-saving practices and push for greater government recognition of community seed banks.

“The government does not support indigenous seed saving. They don’t recognize the seed banks, and we want the conference to tackle that,” he said.

He argued that farmers should be allowed to sell seeds they have saved, provided they receive appropriate training in seed selection and quality management.

“Unless farmers can sell seeds, that is the only time farmers will have seed access. And when they have seed access, they can now have biodiversity. From that, we can have food security,” he said.

Beyond the policy discussions, the conference is also bringing together organizations working on agricultural biodiversity, landscape restoration, agroecology and community-led seed conservation.

Mrs. Catherine Muturi, the Kenya Country Director at Landscape Alliance and Regional Convener for East Africa, said farmers and local communities play an important role in conserving biodiversity, maintaining traditional knowledge and ensuring access to planting materials.

She said efforts to restore landscapes should also recognize the importance of native tree seeds and the communities that conserve them.

“Farmers and local communities are not just beneficiaries of restoration efforts. They are important actors in conserving, managing, and supplying tree seed sources. Their knowledge, participation and leadership must be recognised and strengthened,” Muturi said.

Continue Reading

Resource Center

Legal Framework

READ BY CATEGORY

Facebook

Newsletter

Subscribe to Witness Radio's news and report updates



Trending

Subscribe to Witness Radio's news and report updates